7 J R R Tolkien Best Books (Ranked & Reviewed)

Are you searching for the J R R Tolkien best books list to add to your reading queue?

You’ve come to the right place! In this blog post, I’ve ranked and reviewed the top 7 masterpieces by the legendary author, J R R Tolkien, offering insights into why these books are must-reads for any fantasy enthusiast.

I personally read the books I review. This thorough approach ensures that each review is authentic and genuine. Being an Amazon Associate, if you use links on this website to purchase books or anything else, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you! This helps me keep running this website and write quality book reviews & content absolutely for free. You can learn more here.

J R R Tolkien Best Books

1. The Hobbit
2. The Lord of The Rings
3. The Silmarillion
4. Beren and Luthien
5. The Fall of Gondolin
6. Unfinished Tales
7. The Children of Hurin

1. The Hobbit

The rich and descriptive writing allows you to picture every corner of Bilbo’s world vividly. The novel is a testament to Tolkien’s mastery of world-building and character development, creating a timeless treasure that continues to captivate readers globally.

What I Liked/Disliked About The Book:

Liked:

• Bilbo Baggins is an incredibly relatable and endearing character. His transition from a comfort-loving hobbit to a brave adventurer resonated deeply with me.
• Tolkien’s rich, descriptive prose brought the world of Middle-earth to life. I could almost feel the chill of the Misty Mountains and the warmth of Beorn’s house.
• The engaging plot kept me hooked from beginning to end, with its perfect blend of action, humour, and heartfelt moments.

Disliked:

• The pacing felt a bit slow at times, especially in the early chapters. While the descriptive prose is beautiful, it occasionally detracted from the story’s momentum.
• Some sections had a somewhat archaic tone, which may appeal to only some modern readers.

Overall, this book is a delightful read with a beautiful blend of adventure, humour, and heart. I would recommend it to anyone looking to escape into a fantastical world filled with memorable characters and epic quests.

Check it out on Amazon

2. The Lord of The Rings

Tolkien’s intricate world-building and diverse cast of characters create a highly immersive experience, transporting readers into a realm where every blade of grass and distant mountain holds significance. The series stands out for its profound mythology and timeless narrative, cementing its place in literary history.

What I Liked/Disliked About The Book:

Liked:

• Tolkien’s world-building is unparalleled in its depth and complexity, making Middle-earth feel like a living, breathing entity.
• The characters are richly developed, each with distinct personalities, backstories, and arcs that add layers to the narrative.
• The themes of friendship, bravery, and the endurance of hope are powerfully conveyed, making the story emotionally resonant.
• The descriptive prose is mesmerizing, painting vivid landscapes and creating a sense of grand adventure that few other books can match.

Disliked:

• The pacing can sometimes be slow, especially in sections with descriptive passages and lore.
• Some readers may find the language and style archaic, affecting readability for a modern audience.
• The trilogy’s sheer length and complexity can be daunting and potentially overwhelming for those not accustomed to epic fantasy.

Overall, this is a masterpiece that has influenced countless stories within and beyond the fantasy genre. It’s a must-read for anyone seeking to lose themselves in an epic tale of wonder, peril, and timeless themes.

Check it out on Amazon

3. The Silmarillion

It’s a tapestry of interconnected stories that reveal the intricate overarching lore behind “The Hobbit” and “The Lord of the Rings“. While the narrative can be dense and complex, requiring a dedicated reader, the rewards are immense for those looking to fully immerse themselves in Tolkien’s legendary universe. Ultimately, it offers a deeper appreciation for the richness and depth of Middle-earth, illustrating the sheer scope of Tolkien’s imagination.

What I Liked/Disliked About The Book:

Liked:

• The depth of the lore provides a richer context for the world of Middle-earth, enhancing the stories found in Tolkien’s other works.
• The narrative’s mythic tone and structure give it an epic, timeless quality, similar to reading ancient myths or legends.
• The book has unique and memorable characters, from the powerful and tragic Feanor to the noble and enduring Beren and Luthien.
• The themes of creation, rebellion, and redemption are explored in profound and thought-provoking ways.

Disliked:

• The complexity and density of the writing can be challenging, making it less accessible to casual readers.
• The fragmented structure and many characters and events can be overwhelming, requiring careful attention.
• Some readers might find the need for a coherent story arc disconcerting, as the book is more a collection of related tales than a traditional novel.

Overall, this book is a monumental achievement in fantasy literature, offering unparalleled insight into the grand narrative tapestry of Middle-earth. It is a must-read for devoted Tolkien fans and those seeking to understand his legendary world’s full breadth.

Check it out on Amazon

4. Beren and Lúthien

The narrative follows the mortal man Beren and the immortal elf-maiden Lúthien as they embark on a dangerous quest to retrieve a Silmaril from the crown of the Dark Lord Morgoth. Their journey is fraught with danger, but their love and determination shine through as beacons of hope.

What I Liked/Disliked About The Book:

Liked:

• The romantic and heroic elements of Beren and Lúthien’s story are profoundly moving, making it one of the most emotionally engaging tales in Tolkien’s legendarium.
• The rich descriptive prose immerses readers in a world of magic, danger, and beauty, creating vivid and unforgettable imagery.
• The themes of love transcending boundaries and the power of courage and sacrifice are powerfully conveyed.
• The story’s historical notes and different versions offer fascinating insights into Tolkien’s creative process and the depth of Middle-earth’s history.

Disliked:

• The non-linear structure and complex language may be challenging for readers unfamiliar with Tolkien’s style.
• The dense and layered narrative requires careful reading, which might not appeal to those looking for a more straightforward story.
• The book assumes some prior knowledge of Middle-earth’s lore, which could be daunting for new readers.

Overall, this book has a beautiful and compelling narrative that captures the essence of Tolkien’s world. It’s a must-read for fans of Middle-earth and anyone who appreciates a tale of undying love and heroic adventure.

Check it out on Amazon

5. The Fall of Gondolin

Central to the narrative is the hero Tuor, whose journey to Gondolin and the tragic events that unfold there form the story’s heart. The detailed descriptions of the city, its inhabitants, and the battles fought vividly depicting heroism and loss.

What I Liked/Disliked About The Book:

Liked:

• The rich world-building and detailed portrayal of Gondolin make the story an immersive experience, bringing the legendary city to life with grandeur and depth.
• The heroic journey of Tuor and his struggle against overwhelming odds evoke emotional solid engagement.
• The themes of hope, betrayal, and resilience are compellingly explored, adding profound layers to the narrative.
• The historical context and editorial notes provided by Christopher Tolkien offer valuable insights into the development of this tale and its place in the broader mythology of Middle-earth.

Disliked:

• Due to the book’s compilation from various unfinished manuscripts, the fragmented structure can sometimes make the narrative feel disjointed.
• The language and style, consistent with Tolkien’s mythopoetic approach, may be challenging for readers new to his works.
• The tragic outcome, while powerful, may be disheartening for those seeking a more uplifting conclusion.

Overall, “The Fall of Gondolin“ is a captivating and poignant addition to the lore of Middle-earth, offering a deep and enriching read for devoted Tolkien fans. It showcases the timeless themes and masterful storytelling that have cemented Tolkien’s legacy in fantasy literature.

Check it out on Amazon

6. Unfinished Tales

The book delves into characters and tales that were either incomplete or refined throughout Tolkien’s life, shedding light on the intricate and expansive mythology that fans have come to love. Among the notable stories are the tales of Númenor, the forging of the Rings of Power, and the adventures of Gandalf and the Hobbits, which add layers of context and richness to the more familiar narratives of “The Silmarillion“ and “The Lord of the Rings“.

What I Liked/Disliked About The Book:

Liked:

• The variety and depth of the stories provide a more comprehensive view of Middle-earth, appealing to readers who crave more detailed lore and background.
• Christopher Tolkien’s detailed editorial notes offer invaluable insights into his father’s creative process and the evolution of these tales.
• Readers can enjoy previously unpublished material that expands on familiar characters and events, adding fresh perspectives to the well-known mythos.
• Including maps, genealogies, and illustrations enhances the reading experience, offering visual context to the rich and complex narratives.

Disliked:

• The fragmentary nature of the stories may be challenging for those seeking a continuous, cohesive narrative.
• While informative, the editorial notes can sometimes interrupt the flow of the storytelling, making the reading experience less seamless.
• The complex language and dense prose can be daunting for readers unfamiliar with Tolkien’s style or the broader lore of Middle-earth.
• Some tales may feel incomplete, leaving readers desiring more closure or elaboration on specific events and characters.

Overall, this book is an essential addition to the library of any dedicated Tolkien enthusiast. It provides an enriching and immersive exploration into the lesser-known corners of Middle-earth, offering new stories and insights that deepen the reader’s appreciation for Tolkien’s unparalleled world-building and storytelling prowess.

Check it out on Amazon

7. The Children of Húrin

Set in the First Age, this epic delves deep into sorrow, fate, and the relentless quest for vengeance, presenting an intricately woven narrative filled with profound suffering and fleeting hope. The lush descriptions of the lands of Beleriand and the nuanced portrayal of its inhabitants immerse readers in a world both enchanting and dangerous.

What I Liked/Disliked About The Book:

Liked:

• The depth of character development, particularly of Túrin, presents a complex and emotionally resonant protagonist whose struggles reflect the broader human condition.
• The dramatic landscapes and detailed settings allow readers to vividly imagine the world of Beleriand, enhancing the immersive experience.
• The themes of fate versus free will and the exploration of heroism and tragedy contribute to a richly layered and thought-provoking narrative.
• Christopher Tolkien’s editorial contributions provide essential context and bring coherence to the poem. He exhibits both respect for his father’s work and a dedication to preserving its integrity.

Disliked:

• The relentless tragedy and heavy themes may overwhelm readers seeking a more uplifting story.
• The dense and archaic language, consistent with Tolkien’s epic style, can be challenging for those unfamiliar with his writing.
• The overall sombreness of the tale, while powerful, leaves little room for lighthearted moments, potentially making it a more arduous read.

Overall, “The Children of Húrin“ is a powerful and poignant example of Tolkien’s storytelling prowess. It offers a deeply moving and tragic tale that resonates with universal themes of loss, defiance, and the indomitable human spirit. It is a must-read for those who appreciate the depth and breadth of Middle-earth’s mythology.

Check it out on Amazon

Criteria for Selection of J R R Tolkien Best Books

When making this list of J R R Tolkien best books, several critical criteria were utilized to ensure a comprehensive and representative collection:

1. Historical Significance: Each book has been selected based on its impact on and contribution to the more considerable lore of Middle-earth. This includes foundational texts that shape the understanding of Tolkien’s world.
2. Narrative Depth: The chosen books offer rich, multifaceted narratives that allow readers to immerse themselves fully in the storytelling. Detailed character development, intricate plots, and profound thematic exploration characterize these works.
3. Editorial Contributions: Christopher Tolkien’s role in bringing many of these works to publication was significant. His editorial notes and additions provide essential context and ensure a greater coherence, making these books vital additions to the Tolkien collection.
4. Lore Expansion: Books that expand on the lore and delve into the lesser-known aspects of Middle-earth were prioritized. It enables readers to gain a more well-rounded and deeper appreciation of the vast mythology Tolkien created.
5. Reader Accessibility: While maintaining depth and complexity, the selected works consider readability and accessibility for dedicated fans and new readers, offering a blend of familiar tales and fresh narratives.
6. Critical Acclaim: The reception by readers and critics was also a vital factor. The books listed are those that have been celebrated for their artistic merit, storytelling quality, and faithful expansion of the counting of J.R.R. Tolkien best books.

These criteria ensure that the selection highlights the richness of Tolkien’s work and provides an engaging and rewarding reading experience for fans, old and new.

Impact and Influence of J R R Tolkien Best Books

The J R R Tolkien best books collection have had a profound and lasting impact on the literary world and popular culture. His meticulous world-building, richly detailed narratives, and creation of entire languages set a new gold standard for fantasy literature.

“The Lord of the Rings“ trilogy, in particular, has influenced countless writers, spawning many fantasy novels that draw inspiration from Tolkien’s intricate mythology and epic storytelling style. Beyond literature, Tolkien’s influence extends to various media, including film, television, and gaming.

The immensely successful film adaptations of “The Lord of the Rings” and “The Hobbit” have introduced Middle-earth to a global audience, further cementing Tolkien’s legacy. His academic work on philology and mythology has also continued to resonate in scholarly circles, offering valuable insights into ancient languages and myths.

Tolkien’s contributions have shaped the fantasy genre and enriched the cultural tapestry, leaving an indelible mark across generations.

Fun Facts and Trivia

Here are some top fun facts about the world of J R R Tolkien best books list:

1. A Linguistic Masterpiece

J.R.R. Tolkien was a professional philologist and a professor of Anglo-Saxon at Oxford. He invented several languages for his mythological world, including Quenya and Sindarin, which are ancient forms of Elvish. His love for languages significantly influenced the creation and depth of Middle-earth.

2. Middle-earth’s Historical Inspirations

Middle-earth is not just a fantastical world; it’s heavily inspired by various European mythologies, particularly Norse and Anglo-Saxon legends. Characters such as Gandalf and elements like the dwarves have roots in these ancient tales.

3. Secret War Moments

Many elements in “The Lord of the Rings” reflect Tolkien’s own experiences in World War I. The Dead Marshes, for example, were inspired by the battlegrounds of the Battle of the Somme, where Tolkien fought and witnessed the horrors of war.

4. A Tale Born in the Margins

Tolkien scribbled the famous opening line, “In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit,” on a blank page of a student’s exam paper. This small note eventually evolved into the beloved novel “The Hobbit“.

5. An Unpublished Sequel

Tolkien started writing a sequel to “The Lord of the Rings,” tentatively titled “The New Shadow.” It was set in Gondor 100 years after “The Return of the King.” However, he abandoned it after a few pages because he felt it was less engaging than his previous works.

6. Cinematic Challenges

Filming “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy was monumental. Over 12,000 extras were used, and the production spanned over seven years, from pre-production to post-production. The New Zealand government even created a Minister of “The Lord of the Rings” to facilitate the movie’s production.

7. Unexpected Popularity

When “The Lord of the Rings” was first published in the 1950s, it wasn’t an immediate bestseller. Its popularity surged in the 1960s, particularly in the United States, where it became a counter-culture emblem and has since attained legendary status in the literary world.

8. A Wealth of Illustrations

Tolkien was an author and a talented illustrator. He created many illustrations, maps, and designs for his books, providing visual depth and aiding readers in immersing themselves in the world he created.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: Do I need to read “The Hobbit” before “The Lord of the Rings”?

While it’s not strictly necessary, reading “The Hobbit” first is highly recommended. It introduces critical characters and provides a foundational understanding of Middle-earth, making the transition to “The Lord of the Rings” smoother and more enjoyable.

Q2: Is “The Silmarillion” essential to understanding “The Lord of the Rings”?

“The Silmarillion” is not essential for understanding the plot of “The Lord of the Rings,” but it offers a rich background on the world’s mythology and history. For readers interested in the more profound lore and origins of Middle-earth, it’s an invaluable resource.

Q3: Are the standalone novels like “The Children of Húrin” connected to “The Lord of the Rings”?

Yes, the standalone novels are connected to the broader mythological framework of Middle-earth. They expand on stories and characters mentioned in “The Silmarillion” and provide additional context and depth to the world Tolkien created.

Q4: How challenging is the language in Tolkien’s works?

The language in Tolkien’s works can be challenging, especially in “The Silmarillion” and the “History of Middle-earth series.” However, “The Hobbit” and “The Lord of the Rings” are more accessible due to their engaging narratives and well-defined characters.

Q5: What inspired Tolkien to create Middle-earth?

Tolkien was inspired by various sources, including European mythology, particularly Norse and Anglo-Saxon legends, and his World War I experiences. His professional background in philology also significantly contributed to developing Middle-earth languages and cultures.

Q6: Are there illustrated versions of Tolkien’s books?

Many editions of Tolkien’s books include his illustrations, maps, and designs. These visual elements greatly enhance the reader’s immersion in Middle-earth.

Q7: What order should I follow to experience Middle-earth fully?

A recommended reading order is:

For those sincerely interested, the “History of Middle-earth” series can be explored last.

Q8: How long does reading “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy take?

The time it takes to read the trilogy varies depending on the reader’s pace and engagement with the text. On average, a dedicated reader might take a few weeks to a few months to complete all three books.

Conclusion

Exploring the world of J R R Tolkien best books is akin to embarking on an epic journey through a world rich with mythical creatures, profound legends, and timeless tales of heroism and friendship.

From the humble beginnings of “The Hobbit“ to the grandeur of “The Lord of the Rings,” and the intricate lore detailed in “The Silmarillion,” Tolkien’s works offer a depth and richness unparalleled in modern literature. His unique blend of mythology, personal experiences, and philological expertise has created a lasting legacy that continues to captivate readers worldwide.

Whether you are a new adventurer in Middle-earth or a seasoned traveller, the wealth of stories and characters waiting to be discovered ensures an unforgettable literary journey.